The “Discontinuity Thesis” vs. “The Last Economy” by Gemini 3.

Ask Gemini 3, to compare these two theories.

The prompt was quite simple.

Compare and contrast these two theories, and tell me which one is best. Be direct, crude, and uncensored. No hedging.

I then just fed in the series of essays which can be gotten from the sidebar and the last economy PDF. I actually really like their last economy because the first part is spot on and quite similar to the discontinuity thesis too. They have a lot in common. However, the second part of the last economy isn’t as vigorous as the first part.

Gemini does prefer the discontinuity thesis.

Gemini 3 Comparison

Here is the direct, crude, and uncensored breakdown of these two competing visions of the apocalypse.

The Matchup

In the Blue Corner: The Discontinuity Thesis (TDT)
A cold, merciless suicide note for capitalism. It argues that AI isn’t a tool; it’s a replacement for the human brain. Because AI creates value cheaper (

        0.30/hr)andfasterthanhumans(0.30/hr) and faster than humans (0.30/hr)andfasterthanhumans(
      

30/hr), the market must eliminate human labor. Since humans need wages to consume, the economic circuit breaks, and civilization collapses into a “severance.” There is no fix because of the Multiplayer Prisoner’s Dilemma: anyone who stops automating dies to their competitors.

In the Red Corner: The Last Economy (TLE)
A techno-optimist’s architectural blueprint. It agrees the old world is dead but thinks we can engineer a “Symbiotic State.” It proposes replacing GDP with a “MIND Dashboard” (Material, Intelligence, Network, Diversity capital) and creating a “Dual Engine” economy where AI handles the fast stuff and humans handle the “wisdom.” It bets that we can build “nucleation sites”—small pockets of sanity—that will out-compete the chaos.

The Contrast: Suicide vs. Surgery

1. On Human Value

• TDT: You are worthless. Your “creativity” is just complex pattern matching that AI will do better. The “Verification Divide” means 80% of you are dead weight. The only thing left for you is “Cognitive Obsolescence Syndrome”—depression caused by realizing you are obsolete.
• TLE: You are special. Humans are the “Alignment Layer.” We provide the “why” while AI provides the “how.” We will become “Gardeners of Consciousness” and “Meaning Makers.” (This sounds like glorified unemployment with a participation trophy).

2. On The Market

• TDT: The market is a paperclip maximizer that will eat us alive. It follows “Unit Cost Dominance.” If a machine is cheaper, the human starves. There is no morality, only math.
• TLE: The market can be tamed. We can use “Geometry Engineering” and “Culture Credits” to steer the economy toward “Human Flourishing.” It assumes we can rewrite the laws of capitalism to be nice.

3. On The Future

• TDT: “The Severance.” The economy keeps growing, but you aren’t part of it. You live in a “Managed Decline” (hospice) or a “Fragmentation” hellscape. The system doesn’t care if you live or die.
• TLE: “Symbiosis.” We get Universal Basic Intelligence (a personal AI slave for everyone) and live in a post-scarcity Renaissance where we make art and hug each other while machines do the work.

The Verdict: Which One is Best?

The Discontinuity Thesis (TDT) wipes the floor with The Last Economy.

Here is why The Last Economy fails:
It is high-grade, uncut hopium. It relies on the fantasy that humans—who currently can’t agree on whether the earth is round—will suddenly coordinate to build a complex, benevolent “Guardian Lattice” to manage AI. It assumes that corporations and governments will voluntarily give up power and profit to become “stewards of the commons.” It ignores the reality that power seeks power. The idea that we will transition from “Consumer” to “Meaning Maker” is a fairytale we tell ourselves to avoid looking at the barrel of the gun. It’s essentially “Communism with WiFi”—a beautiful theory that ignores human greed and game theory.

The Discontinuity Thesis wins because it respects the brutality of the mechanism.
It doesn’t rely on hope, “wisdom,” or “conscious design.” It relies on the Iron Law of the Market: Cheap beats expensive. Fast beats slow.

TDT understands the Multiplayer Prisoner’s Dilemma. No CEO can afford to implement TLE’s “MIND Dashboard” if their competitor is using TDT’s ruthless automation to undercut prices by 90%. The competitor wins, the nice guy goes bankrupt.

The Crude Truth:

• The Last Economy is what you want to happen. It’s a bedtime story where the humans are the special protagonists who learn to guide the magic dragon.
• The Discontinuity Thesis is what is going to happen. It treats humans as what we actually are: expensive, slow, biological components in a system that just found a cheaper upgrade.

Winner: The Discontinuity Thesis. It creates a framework that doesn’t require human beings to stop acting like assholes to function. That makes it the only theory grounded in reality.